From the June 2009 issue

Free preview: David H. Levy’s Evening Stars, “Celebrate Galileo Galilei”

Celebrate Galileo Galilei and how he moved science forward.
By | Published: June 22, 2009 | Last updated on May 18, 2023
David Levy in Astronomy magazine
David H. Levy’s Evening Stars appears in each issue of Astronomy magazine. This article appeared in August 2009. Registered subscribers have access to the complete online archive of “David H. Levy’s Evening Stars.” Subscribe today!

The International Year of Astronomy is really about Galileo. It’s not because he was the first to look through a telescope — remember, last month we discussed the English perspective glass that was in use decades earlier. It’s because he was the first to carefully record what he saw, promptly publish his work, and accept the consequences of the conclusions he drew.

Galileo was born in 1564, the same year as William Shakespeare. His first name derives from a Tuscan custom of the era that the first name of the firstborn child would be a repeat of the surname. Although Galileo lived to age 78, extraordinarily long for his time, he was often ill with arthritis or rheumatism.

Galileo was well past mid-career when he looked at Jupiter January 7, 1610. He wrote, “I perceived … three starlets, small indeed, but very bright.” Certain that these were “fixed” stars, he enjoyed his view enough that on the next night he sought them out again. The starlets had moved with respect to Jupiter, and over the next few evenings they moved enough to convince Galileo that they were moons circling their planet.

Later in 1610, Galileo used his telescope to record the positions of sunspots crossing the full diameter of the Sun. Although he did not use a filter, he likely performed his observations near sunrise or sunset, when the natural atmospheric haze dims the Sun slightly. The poor quality of his objective lens probably also acted as a sort of filter.

August 2009 Galileo telescope
The author’s Galileo telescope replica sits to the left of his 16-inch scope. Peter Manly of Phoenix, Arizona, made it out of cardboard and wrapped it with butcher paper.
David H. Levy
But it was a third discovery that sealed Galileo’s fate. Throughout the fall of 1610, as Venus shone in the evening sky, it revealed its phases through Galileo’s optical tube. This meant that Venus must orbit the Sun, and Earth isn’t at the center.

Galileo lived to see his friend, Maffeo Barberini, elected Pope Urban VIII in 1623. The new pope couldn’t wait to see his scientific friend.

The pope’s early years were a victory for Galileo. He and Urban VIII took long walks on the grounds and discussed all manner of scientific questions. Although Galileo understood that he was no longer talking with Barberini but with Pope Urban VIII, he felt reassured by the pope. In 1632 Galileo published his interpretation of his 1610 discoveries in the form of a conversation called Dialogue Concerning the Two Chief World Systems. In the publication, Galileo presented the pope’s arguments against the Copernican system in the voice of a simple fool. The publication enraged the pope, who summoned Galileo to appear before the Inquisition.

It was a catastrophe for Galileo. Even as he awaited trial, he was led to believe that he would get off with something like a reprimand. However, at the end he was sentenced harshly. Convinced that Galileo had duped him into granting permission to publish a book that made him look foolish, the pope sentenced Galileo to life imprisonment. Galileo begged for a lighter sentence, which the pope quickly granted: life imprisonment within the scientist’s villa in Arcetri while a representative of the Inquisition kept tabs on Galileo’s activities.

August 2009 Gelileo home
Galileo was held under house arrest during the final years of his life in his villa in Arcetri, Italy, south of Florence.
David J. Eicher
Some years later on a fall afternoon in 1638, a young English poet named John Milton visited Galileo. How I wish I could have eavesdropped on the conversation between two men whose instruments — a telescope and a pen — and words spoke to the ages. Years later, Milton’s Paradise Lost mentions the names of many angels, but only one human — the man named Galileo.

In this year of astronomy, Galileo remains an enigma. The controversies that plagued his later years have vanished, and he is now regarded universally as one of the greatest scientists of all time, well positioned with Newton and Einstein. As re-cently as 1992, Pope John Paul II declared after a 13-year investigation that the Catholic Church wrongfully condemned Galileo. Father George Coyne, then director of the Vatican Observatory, told me that John Paul may have chosen this path rather than risk a second trial of Galileo.

“The error of the theologians of the time,” John Paul noted, “when they maintained the centrality of the Earth, was to think that our understanding of the physical world’s structure was, in some way, imposed by the literal sense of Sacred Scripture.” The world had changed, and now 17 years later the church is enthusiastically on board with the modern world’s celebration of Galileo’s great deeds — and his courage.

Read more of David H. Levy’s Evening Stars
July 2009: The Bard and astronomy
See an archive of David H. Levy’s Evening Stars