Catching the birth of a black hole

According to a new analysis, just before a black hole forms, a dying star may generate a distinct burst of light that will allow astronomers to witness the birth of a new black hole for the first time.
By | Published: May 6, 2013
Light distortions created by a black hole
A computer-generated image of the light distortions created by a black hole. // Alain Riazuelo, IAP/UPMC/CNRS
When a massive star exhausts its fuel, it collapses under its own gravity and produces a black hole, an object so dense that not even light can escape its gravitational grip. According to a new analysis by an astrophysicist at the California Institute of Technology (Caltech) in Pasadena, just before the black hole forms, the dying star may generate a distinct burst of light that will allow astronomers to witness the birth of a new black hole for the first time.

While some dying stars that result in black holes explode as gamma-ray bursts, which are among the most energetic phenomena in the universe, those cases are rare, requiring exotic circumstances, said Tony Piro from Caltech. “We don’t think most run-of-the-mill black holes are created that way.” In most cases, according to one hypothesis, a dying star produces a black hole without a bang or a flash: The star would seemingly vanish from the sky — an event dubbed an unnova. “You don’t see a burst,” he said. “You see a disappearance.”

But, Piro hypothesized, that may not be the case. “Maybe they’re not as boring as we thought,” he said.

According to well-established theory, when a massive star dies, its core collapses under its own weight. As it collapses, the protons and electrons that make up the core merge and produce neutrons. For a few seconds — before it ultimately collapses into a black hole — the core becomes an extremely dense object called a neutron star, which is as dense as the Sun would be if squeezed into a sphere with a radius of about 6 miles (10 kilometers). This collapsing process also creates neutrinos, which are particles that zip through almost all matter at nearly the speed of light. As the neutrinos stream out from the core, they carry away a lot of energy, representing about a tenth of the Sun’s mass.

According to a little-known paper written in 1980 by Dmitry Nadezhin of the Alikhanov Institute for Theoretical and Experimental Physics in Russia, this rapid loss of mass means that the gravitational strength of the dying star’s core would abruptly drop. When that happens, the outer gaseous layers — mainly hydrogen — still surrounding the core would rush outward, generating a shock wave that would hurtle through the outer layers at about 2 million mph (3.2 million km/h).

Using computer simulations, two astronomers at the University of California-Santa Cruz, Elizabeth Lovegrove and Stan Woosley, recently found that when the shock wave strikes the outer surface of the gaseous layers, it would heat the gas at the surface, producing a glow that would shine for about a year — a potentially promising signal of a black hole birth. Although about a million times brighter than the Sun, this glow would be relatively dim compared to other stars. “It would be hard to see, even in galaxies that are relatively close to us,” said Piro.

But now Piro said he has found a more promising signal. In his new study, he examined in more detail what might happen at the moment when the shock wave hits the star’s surface, and he calculated that the impact itself would make a flash 10 to 100 times brighter than the glow predicted by Lovegrove and Woosley. “That flash is going to be very bright, and it gives us the best chance for actually observing that this event occurred,” Piro said. “This is what you really want to look for.”

Such a flash would be dim compared to exploding stars called supernovae, for example, but it would be luminous enough to be detectable in nearby galaxies, he said. The flash, which would shine for three to 10 days before fading, would be very bright in optical wavelengths — and at its very brightest in ultraviolet wavelengths.

Piro estimated that astronomers should be able to see one of these events per year on average. Surveys that watch the skies for flashes of light like supernovae — surveys such as the Palomar Transient Factory (PTF), led by Caltech — are well-suited to discover these unique events, he said. The intermediate Palomar Transient Factory (iPTF), which improves on the PTF and just began surveying in February, may be able to find a couple of these events per year.

Neither survey has observed any black-hole flashes as of yet, said Piro, but that does not rule out their existence. “Eventually, we’re going to start getting worried if we don’t find these things.” But for now, he said, his expectations are perfectly sound.

With Piro’s analysis in hand, astronomers should be able to design and fine-tune additional surveys to maximize their chances of witnessing a black hole birth in the near future. In 2015, the next generation of PTF, called the Zwicky Transient Facility (ZTF), is slated to begin; it will be even more sensitive, improving by several times the chances of finding those flashes. “Caltech is therefore really well-positioned to look for transient events like this,” Piro said.

Within the next decade, the Large Synoptic Survey Telescope (LSST) will begin a massive survey of the entire night sky. “If LSST isn’t regularly seeing these kinds of events, then that’s going to tell us that maybe there’s something wrong with this picture, or that black-hole formation is much rarer than we thought,” he said.