Two solar system puzzles solved

An unstable disk surrounding the early Sun could answer long-standing questions about the composition of comets.
By | Published: July 25, 2012 | Last updated on May 18, 2023

Gemini Sparkle

Key Takeaways:

  • Boss and Alexander developed a model simulating refractory particle trajectories within a gravitationally unstable, three-dimensional protoplanetary disk, assuming a young Sun experiencing outbursts.
  • Their calculations demonstrated that centimeter-sized refractory particles, analogous to CAIs, could migrate from the hot inner disk to the frigid outer regions, where they could be incorporated into growing comets.
  • The model also revealed that these particles experienced complex, back-and-forth journeys within the disk, leading to evaporation and condensation processes that resulted in the acquisition of varied compositional rims.
  • This chaotic transport mechanism provides a unified explanation for both the presence of high-temperature refractory materials in icy comets and the observed diverse oxygen isotopic compositions and peculiar rim structures in meteorite particles.
Key takeaways sponsored by The Space Store
BossAlexanderTrajectoriesSolSys
Comets and asteroids preserve the building blocks of our solar system and should help explain its origin. But there are unsolved puzzles. For example, how did icy comets obtain particles that formed at high temperatures, and how did these refractory particles acquire rims with different compositions? Alan Boss and Conel Alexander from the Carnegie Institution for Science in Washington, D.C., are the first to model the trajectories of such particles in the unstable disk of gas and dust that formed the solar system. They found that these refractory particles could have begun in the hot inner disk and then traveled out to the frigid outer regions to end up in icy comets. The particles’ meandering trips back and forth could help explain the different compositions of their rims.

The young Sun likely experienced a series of outbursts caused by the rapid infall of disk gas. The leading mechanism for explaining such outbursts is a temporary phase of disk instability. The researchers modeled the trajectories of several hundred centimeter-sized melilite mineral particles during such a phase. These particles are similar to calcium-aluminum-rich inclusions (CAIs), the refractory particles often found in well-preserved meteorites, as well as Comet 81P/Wild.

Their disk model assumed a gravitationally unstable three-dimensional disk with a mass of about 5 percent of today’s Sun and temperatures ranging from a frigid -350° Fahrenheit (-210 Celsius) in the outer regions to a scorching 2240° F (1230° C) near the center. Their calculations allowed the CAIs to orbit in the disk while being subjected to gas drag and the gravity of both the disk and the Sun.

The particles started orbiting in unison, but after about 20 years their trajectories began to diverge significantly. Most struck the inner boundary of the disk at 1 astronomical unit (AU, the Earth/Sun distance), while others went to the outer boundary at 10 AU where they could be swept up in a growing comet. About 10 percent migrated back and forth in the disk before hitting one of the two boundaries.

The researchers then modeled the evaporation and condensation processes that the particles would experience during their migrations. They found that such particles were likely to acquire outer rims with varied compositions recently shown to indicate CAIs.

“CAIs are thought to have formed at the very beginning of the solar system,” said Alexander. “Our results show that they must have experienced remarkably complex histories as they were transported chaotically all over the disk.”

These migrations could explain the different oxygen isotopes that have been found in particles from meteorites. These are varieties of oxygen atoms with different numbers of neutrons that point to different processing conditions for the particle rims.

Previous work by Boss had shown that oxygen isotope abundances could vary in an unstable disk, resulting in the range found in meteorites. Coupled with the new results, these models show that several puzzles may have been solved: an unstable disk can explain both large-scale outward transport of refractory particles, as well as the peculiar rim compositions acquired during their journeys.

“It’s nice to solve two problems at once,” said Boss. “But there are still many more puzzles about meteorites for us to work on.”

Up Next