Year of the Comet
Comet C/2011 L4 (PANSTARRS)

PANSTARRS information

Comet C/2012 S1 (ISON)

ISON information

Astronomy News
E-mail Article to a FriendPrint ArticleBookmark and Share

Faraway Eris is Pluto's twin

A new study proves that the two objects are essentially the same size, while Eris is 27 percent more massive than Pluto.
By ESO, Garching, Germany Published: October 27, 2011
Dwarf-planet-Eris
Artist’s impression of the dwarf planet Eris. Credit: ESO
Astronomers have accurately measured the diameter of the faraway dwarf planet Eris for the first time by catching it as it passed in front of a faint star. This event was seen at the end of 2010 by telescopes in Chile, including the Belgian TRAnsiting Planets and PlanetesImals Small Telescope (TRAPPIST) at the European Southern Observatory’s (ESO) La Silla Observatory. The observations show that Eris is an almost perfect twin of Pluto in size. Eris appears to have a reflective surface, suggesting that it is uniformly covered in a thin layer of ice, probably a frozen atmosphere.

In November 2010, the distant dwarf planet Eris passed in front of a faint background star, an event called an occultation. These occurrences are rare and difficult to observe, as the dwarf planet is distant and small. The next such event involving Eris will not happen until 2013. Occultations provide the most accurate and often the only way to measure the shape and size of a distant solar system body.

Studying pictures from the MPG/ESO 2.2-meter telescope at ESO’s La Silla Observatory in Chile identified the candidate star for the occultation. The observations were carefully planned and carried out by a team of astronomers from a number of universities using, among others, the TRAPPIST telescope.

“Observing occultations by the tiny bodies beyond Neptune in the solar system requires great precision and careful planning. This is the best way to measure Eris’ size, short of actually going there,” said Bruno Sicardy from LESIA at the Paris Observatory in France.

Observations of the occultation were attempted from 26 locations around the globe on the predicted path of the dwarf planet’s shadow, including several telescopes at amateur observatories, but only two sites were able to observe the event directly, both of them located in Chile. One telescope was at ESO’s La Silla Observatory using the TRAPPIST telescope, and the other was located in San Pedro de Atacama and used two telescopes. All three telescopes recorded a sudden drop in brightness as Eris blocked the light of the distant star.

The combined observations from the two Chilean sites indicate that Eris is close to spherical. These measurements should accurately measure its shape and size as long as they are not distorted by the presence of large mountains. Such features are, however, unlikely on such a large icy body.

Eris was identified as a large object in the outer solar system in 2005. Its discovery was one of the factors that led to the creation of a new class of objects called dwarf planets and the reclassification of Pluto from planet to dwarf planet in 2006. Eris is currently three times farther from the Sun than Pluto.

While earlier observations using other methods suggested that Eris was probably about 25 percent larger than Pluto with an estimated diameter of 1,900 miles (3,000 kilometers), the new study proves that the two objects are essentially the same size. Eris’ newly determined diameter stands at 1,400 miles (2,300km), with an accuracy of 7 miles (12km). This makes its size better known than that of its closer counterpart Pluto, which has a diameter estimated to be between 1,400 and 1,500 miles (2,300 and 2,400 km). Pluto’s diameter is harder to measure because the presence of an atmosphere makes its edge impossible to detect directly by occultations. The motion of Eris’ satellite Dysnomia was used to estimate the mass of Eris. It was found to be 27 percent heavier than Pluto.

“This density means that Eris is probably a large rocky body covered in a relatively thin mantle of ice,” said Emmanuel Jehin from the Astrophysical Institute of the University of Liège, Belgium, who contributed to the study.

The surface of Eris was found to be extremely reflective, reflecting 96 percent of the light that falls on it — a visible albedo of 0.96. This is even brighter than fresh snow on Earth, making Eris one of the most reflective objects in the solar system along with Saturn’s icy moon Enceladus. The bright surface of Eris is most likely composed of a nitrogen-rich ice mixed with frozen methane, as indicated by the object’s spectrum, coating the dwarf planet’s surface in a thin and reflective icy layer less than .04 inch (1 millimeter) thick.

“This layer of ice could result from the dwarf planet’s nitrogen or methane atmosphere condensing as frost onto its surface as it moves away from the Sun in its elongated orbit and into an increasingly cold environment,” Jehin said. The ice could then turn back to gas as Eris approaches its closest point to the Sun at a distance of about 3.5 billion miles (5.7 billion km).

The new results also allow the team to make a new measurement for the surface temperature of the dwarf planet. The estimates suggest a temperature for the surface facing the Sun of –396° Fahrenheit (–238° Celsius) at most, and an even lower value for the night side of Eris.

“It is extraordinary how much we can find out about a small and distant object such as Eris by watching it pass in front of a faint star, using relatively small telescopes. Five years after the creation of the new class of dwarf planets, we are finally really getting to know one of its founding members,” said Bruno Sicardy.

Find us on FacebookFind us on Twitter
User Comments
Be the first to leave your comment below!

Only registered members of Astronomy.com are allowed to comment on this article. Registration is FREE and only takes a couple minutes.

Register Today!
 
5 stars
BRENT CAISTER said:
Very interesting story.
SAM NAUMAN from TEXAS said:
I do not see what problem people have in classifying Pluto as a minor planet. It is a minor planet, though still a planet. This is no different to cars being classified as sub-compact, compact, midsize and large. I personally do not feel nostalgic about Pluto. Lets move on. The decision has been made.
4 stars
LAUREL KORNFELD from NEW JERSEY said:
As an astronomer who has been advocating Pluto's planet status for five years, I emphasize that yes, those of us who insist Pluto is a solar system planet also insist that Eris, Ceres, Haumea, Makemake, and likely many other dwarf planets are solar system planets too. This data, which shows that Eris is marginally smaller than Pluto though more massive, means the decision made by four percent of the IAU in 2006 was based on erroneous information (specifically, the belief that Eris was larger than Pluto) and was therefore premature. The so-called "requirements" for planets versus dwarf planets are not facts; they were deliberately concocted to artificially keep the number of solar system planets small. Dr. Alan Stern coined the term "dwarf planet" in 1991, but he meant it to designate a third class of planets in addition to terrestrials and jovians, small planets large enough to be rounded by their own gravity but not large enough to gravitationally dominate their orbits. He never intended for dwarf planets to not be considered planets at all. So what if the number of solar system planets constantly changes? We don't limit the number of rivers or mountains on Earth so kids can memorize them. Memorization is not even important to education; what is more important is that kids--and adults--understand the different types of planets and the characteristics of each one. For more on why Pluto and dwarf planets are planets, visit my Pluto Blog at http://laurelsplutoblog.blogspot.com .
5 stars
MIKE WRATHELL from MICHIGAN said:
It appears, given the present data, that Pluto is more likely than not, larger than Eris. Of course, they are not twins. Christopher Marlowe once said, "Comparisons are odious." He was born the same year as Shakespeare and must have grown quite weary of the comparisons. I have read them both and they are both great playwrights in their own right, just as Pluto and Eris are wonderful planets. Like Venus and Mars, who are both beautiful in their own way, Pluto will reveal its beauty and awe in 2015. Someday, we might sent a spacecraft to Eris, too. In the meantime, must wait for New Horizons to measure Pluto's diameter in 2015. Some wish Eris to be larger so Pluto's case for replanetification will be twarted, but, hopefully, once the data is sent back to Earth in July 2015, the IAU will be forced to admit Pluto got the shaft back in 2006, thanks in part due to highly inaccurate data submitted to it by Mike Brown, the so-called "Pluto killer."
SEARCH SITE
Subscriber Only Access
Subscriber Only Content
Look for this icon. This denotes premium subscriber content. Learn more »
Become a Member of Astronomy.com
Register today for access to more valuable resource information.
Interact in our forums, comment on articles, receive our newsletter and much more!
Not a member?
Subscriber and Member Login
Password
Remember me